That Passport Life with Kevin McCullough

What Was Really on the Table in 1621?

Carbonatix Pre-Player Loader

Audio By Carbonatix

What Was Really on the Table in 1621?

The Harvest Feast at Plimoth Patuxet

If you could pull up a seat at the harvest gathering in Plymouth in 1621, the first surprise might be what’s missing. There’s no evidence of mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce or pumpkin pie as we know it. Turkey is possible, but the one surviving eyewitness account doesn’t name it. Want to know what you could put on the menu with confidence? Start with venison. 

In a letter written in 1621⁠, English colonist Edward Winslow tells us that four men went out hunting birds after the harvest. He also records that the Wampanoag leader Ousamequin, often called Massasoit, came with about 90 men. The gathering lasted three days, and the Wampanoag brought five deer. It’s one of the clearest details we have, and it tells us something about the occasion: Those deer were both food and a diplomatic gift. 

As for the bird, William Bradford separately noted that wild turkeys were plentiful that fall. Ducks and geese are plausible, too. The museum’s historians look to what people grew, gathered, hunted and caught in the area to fill out the picture. Beans, squash, fish and shellfish were all available. Cranberries grew in the region, but that doesn’t put a bowl of sweet cranberry sauce on the table. And a pumpkin in the garden is a long way from a pumpkin pie cooling on the windowsill. 

So how did turkey wind up with top billing? By the 19th century, New Englanders already knew Thanksgiving as a time for family reunions and turkey with the trimmings. In 1841, when the minister and historian Alexander Young republished Winslow’s account, he labeled the gathering the “First Thanksgiving” in a footnote and suggested that the unnamed fowl were wild turkeys. It’s easy to see how a bird people already served at Thanksgiving became the one they pictured at Plymouth. 

If you’re headed to Plymouth, start at the Historic Patuxet Homesite⁠. Step inside a wetu, a traditional home, and ask an educator how Wampanoag families stored food for winter. Then take that same question to the 17th-Century English Village. It’s a simple way to get children thinking about how two communities made a living in the same place. Plimoth Patuxet Museums⁠ is open daily from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. through Sunday, November 29. 

By all means, keep the pie. But when someone asks what they really ate in 1621, tell them about the five deer. That’s where the story gets interesting.

 

Devotionals

View All